In 2000, Al Gore and George W. Bush split the popular vote almost exactly, and so did much of the country: 45% of votes were cast in counties decided by 20 points or more. By 2016 that share had jumped to 61%, and it has stayed there. Most Americans now live in places where one party wins by a landslide, and they increasingly vote like it.
Votes cast in landslide counties
Share of two-party presidential votes cast in counties won by 20+ and 40+ points
Source: MIT Election Data and Science Lab county returns via Outerview election_results
The middle emptied out
Each row is an election; each cell is the share of counties whose result landed in that margin band. Watch the mass move to the right edge. In 2000 the typical county was a Republican-leaning swing county. By 2024 it was a Republican landslide county.
How counties voted, 2000–2024
Share of counties by two-party margin band (D = Democratic margin, R = Republican margin)
Source: MIT Election Data and Science Lab county returns via Outerview election_results
The Democratic coalition has concentrated. In 2000 Gore carried 671 counties; in 2024 Harris carried 474, yet those counties cast 49% of all votes. A party that wins big cities by huge margins and loses most of the map's land area can win the popular vote and still struggle in the Senate and the Electoral College, where geography counts.
Counties won by each party
Number of counties carried in the presidential race
- Republican
- Democrat
Source: MIT Election Data and Science Lab county returns via Outerview election_results
Data & method
County presidential returns, 2000–2024